{"$schema":"https://policywindow.org/critique/api/schema","name":"Critical AI — selection provenance","description":"Selection is an editorial act, made auditable: every critiqued paper traces to a monitored top-tier venue or a disclosed off-list preprint (no silent / cherry-picked targets). The venue tier is resolved live from the determination — never an overstated stored snapshot.","docs":"https://policywindow.org/critique/journals","total":62,"monitored":35,"off_list_disclosed":27,"off_list_silent":0,"tier_realigned":9,"records":[{"id":"conversational-persuasiveness-gpt4","venue":"Nature Human Behaviour","inMonitoredSet":true,"determinedTier":"A","recordedTier":"A","effectiveTier":"A","kind":"monitored","disclosed":true,"offListPeerReviewed":false},{"id":"cultural-tendencies-generative-ai","venue":"Nature Human Behaviour","inMonitoredSet":true,"determinedTier":"A","recordedTier":"A","effectiveTier":"A","kind":"monitored","disclosed":true,"offListPeerReviewed":false},{"id":"human-ai-feedback-loops-bias-amplification","venue":"Nature Human Behaviour","inMonitoredSet":true,"determinedTier":"A","recordedTier":"A","effectiveTier":"A","kind":"monitored","disclosed":true,"offListPeerReviewed":false},{"id":"perceived-human-vs-ai-empathy","venue":"Nature Human Behaviour","inMonitoredSet":true,"determinedTier":"A","recordedTier":"A","effectiveTier":"A","kind":"monitored","disclosed":true,"offListPeerReviewed":false},{"id":"positioning-political-texts-llm-asking-averaging","venue":"Political Analysis","inMonitoredSet":true,"determinedTier":"A","recordedTier":"A","effectiveTier":"A","kind":"monitored","disclosed":true,"offListPeerReviewed":false},{"id":"real-time-ai-sentiment-self-moderation","venue":"Journal of Computer-Mediated Communication","inMonitoredSet":true,"determinedTier":"A","recordedTier":"A","effectiveTier":"A","kind":"monitored","disclosed":true,"offListPeerReviewed":false},{"id":"reducing-political-polarization-ai-conversations","venue":"Journal of Computer-Mediated Communication","inMonitoredSet":true,"determinedTier":"A","recordedTier":"A","effectiveTier":"A","kind":"monitored","disclosed":true,"offListPeerReviewed":false},{"id":"ai-education-learners-eyes-perceptions-challenges","venue":"Frontiers in Education","inMonitoredSet":false,"determinedTier":null,"recordedTier":"exception","effectiveTier":"exception","kind":"off_list","disclosed":true,"offListPeerReviewed":true},{"id":"ai-regulation-support-bayesian-network","venue":"arXiv preprint","inMonitoredSet":false,"determinedTier":null,"recordedTier":"exception","effectiveTier":"exception","kind":"off_list","disclosed":true,"offListPeerReviewed":false},{"id":"genai-college-student-learning-engagement","venue":"Behavioral Sciences","inMonitoredSet":false,"determinedTier":null,"recordedTier":"exception","effectiveTier":"exception","kind":"off_list","disclosed":true,"offListPeerReviewed":true},{"id":"political-ideology-ai-policy-making","venue":"Frontiers in Artificial Intelligence","inMonitoredSet":false,"determinedTier":null,"recordedTier":"exception","effectiveTier":"exception","kind":"off_list","disclosed":true,"offListPeerReviewed":true},{"id":"ai-social-media-political-competition-democracy","venue":"Frontiers in Political Science","inMonitoredSet":false,"determinedTier":null,"recordedTier":"exception","effectiveTier":"exception","kind":"off_list","disclosed":true,"offListPeerReviewed":true},{"id":"ai-technostress-mental-health-sem","venue":"Frontiers in Psychology","inMonitoredSet":false,"determinedTier":null,"recordedTier":"exception","effectiveTier":"exception","kind":"off_list","disclosed":true,"offListPeerReviewed":true},{"id":"ai-voice-similarity-likability-trust","venue":"PLOS ONE","inMonitoredSet":false,"determinedTier":null,"recordedTier":"exception","effectiveTier":"exception","kind":"off_list","disclosed":true,"offListPeerReviewed":true},{"id":"chatgpt-acceptance-higher-education-utaut2","venue":"Frontiers in Education","inMonitoredSet":false,"determinedTier":null,"recordedTier":"exception","effectiveTier":"exception","kind":"off_list","disclosed":true,"offListPeerReviewed":true},{"id":"social-media-images-sociopolitical-sentiment","venue":"PLOS ONE","inMonitoredSet":false,"determinedTier":null,"recordedTier":"exception","effectiveTier":"exception","kind":"off_list","disclosed":true,"offListPeerReviewed":true},{"id":"ai-meets-politics-examining-the-effects-of-differe","venue":"New Media & Society","inMonitoredSet":true,"determinedTier":"B","recordedTier":"A","effectiveTier":"B","kind":"monitored","disclosed":true,"offListPeerReviewed":false},{"id":"being-literate-behaving-literate-a-mixed-methods-a","venue":"New Media & Society","inMonitoredSet":true,"determinedTier":"B","recordedTier":"B","effectiveTier":"B","kind":"monitored","disclosed":true,"offListPeerReviewed":false},{"id":"beyond-disruption-and-invisibility-interactional-c","venue":"New Media & Society","inMonitoredSet":true,"determinedTier":"B","recordedTier":"B","effectiveTier":"B","kind":"monitored","disclosed":true,"offListPeerReviewed":false},{"id":"from-rule-of-law-to-rule-of-algorithm-generative-a","venue":"Big Data & Society","inMonitoredSet":true,"determinedTier":"exception","recordedTier":"A","effectiveTier":"exception","kind":"monitored","disclosed":true,"offListPeerReviewed":false},{"id":"into-the-black-box-laypeople-s-folk-theories-about","venue":"Big Data & Society","inMonitoredSet":true,"determinedTier":"exception","recordedTier":"exception","effectiveTier":"exception","kind":"monitored","disclosed":true,"offListPeerReviewed":false},{"id":"making-genai-valuable-benchmarks-singularities-and","venue":"Big Data & Society","inMonitoredSet":true,"determinedTier":"exception","recordedTier":"exception","effectiveTier":"exception","kind":"monitored","disclosed":true,"offListPeerReviewed":false},{"id":"more-versus-better-artificial-intelligence-incenti","venue":"Organization Science","inMonitoredSet":true,"determinedTier":"S","recordedTier":"S","effectiveTier":"S","kind":"monitored","disclosed":true,"offListPeerReviewed":false},{"id":"the-cybernetic-teammate-a-field-experiment-on-gene","venue":"Organization Science","inMonitoredSet":true,"determinedTier":"S","recordedTier":"S","effectiveTier":"S","kind":"monitored","disclosed":true,"offListPeerReviewed":false},{"id":"the-rise-of-ai-sovereignty","venue":"Big Data & Society","inMonitoredSet":true,"determinedTier":"exception","recordedTier":"exception","effectiveTier":"exception","kind":"monitored","disclosed":true,"offListPeerReviewed":false},{"id":"ai-chatbots-small-labor-effects","venue":"Becker Friedman Institute Working Paper (University of Chicago)","inMonitoredSet":false,"determinedTier":null,"recordedTier":"exception","effectiveTier":"exception","kind":"off_list","disclosed":true,"offListPeerReviewed":false},{"id":"ai-tutoring-rct-active-learning","venue":"Scientific Reports (Nature Portfolio)","inMonitoredSet":false,"determinedTier":null,"recordedTier":"exception","effectiveTier":"exception","kind":"off_list","disclosed":true,"offListPeerReviewed":true},{"id":"genai-classroom-teaching-university-teachers","venue":"PLOS One","inMonitoredSet":false,"determinedTier":null,"recordedTier":"exception","effectiveTier":"exception","kind":"off_list","disclosed":true,"offListPeerReviewed":true},{"id":"llm-effects-unemployment-earnings","venue":"arXiv (econ.GN) preprint","inMonitoredSet":false,"determinedTier":null,"recordedTier":"exception","effectiveTier":"exception","kind":"off_list","disclosed":true,"offListPeerReviewed":false},{"id":"welfare-ai-claimant-preferences","venue":"Nature Communications","inMonitoredSet":false,"determinedTier":null,"recordedTier":"exception","effectiveTier":"exception","kind":"off_list","disclosed":true,"offListPeerReviewed":true},{"id":"ai-empathy-prosocial-behavior-employees","venue":"Frontiers in Psychology","inMonitoredSet":false,"determinedTier":null,"recordedTier":"exception","effectiveTier":"exception","kind":"off_list","disclosed":true,"offListPeerReviewed":true},{"id":"ai-self-preferencing-algorithmic-hiring","venue":"arXiv (working paper)","inMonitoredSet":false,"determinedTier":null,"recordedTier":"exception","effectiveTier":"exception","kind":"off_list","disclosed":true,"offListPeerReviewed":false},{"id":"local-us-officials-views-ai-governance","venue":"PLOS One","inMonitoredSet":false,"determinedTier":null,"recordedTier":"exception","effectiveTier":"exception","kind":"off_list","disclosed":true,"offListPeerReviewed":true},{"id":"postgraduate-students-perceptions-ai-research-plos","venue":"PLOS One","inMonitoredSet":false,"determinedTier":null,"recordedTier":"exception","effectiveTier":"exception","kind":"off_list","disclosed":true,"offListPeerReviewed":true},{"id":"racial-disparities-time-to-recidivism","venue":"arXiv (cs.CY; stat.AP) preprint","inMonitoredSet":false,"determinedTier":null,"recordedTier":"exception","effectiveTier":"exception","kind":"off_list","disclosed":true,"offListPeerReviewed":false},{"id":"when-ai-judges-your-work","venue":"arXiv (working paper)","inMonitoredSet":false,"determinedTier":null,"recordedTier":"exception","effectiveTier":"exception","kind":"off_list","disclosed":true,"offListPeerReviewed":false},{"id":"genai-usage-university-students-harmful-helpful","venue":"International Journal of Educational Technology in Higher Education","inMonitoredSet":false,"determinedTier":null,"recordedTier":"exception","effectiveTier":"exception","kind":"off_list","disclosed":true,"offListPeerReviewed":true},{"id":"inconsistent-advice-chatgpt-decision-making","venue":"Scientific Reports","inMonitoredSet":false,"determinedTier":null,"recordedTier":"exception","effectiveTier":"exception","kind":"off_list","disclosed":true,"offListPeerReviewed":true},{"id":"student-perspectives-generative-ai-higher-ed","venue":"International Journal for Educational Integrity","inMonitoredSet":false,"determinedTier":null,"recordedTier":"exception","effectiveTier":"exception","kind":"off_list","disclosed":true,"offListPeerReviewed":true},{"id":"cultural-bias-alignment-llms","venue":"PNAS Nexus","inMonitoredSet":false,"determinedTier":null,"recordedTier":"exception","effectiveTier":"exception","kind":"off_list","disclosed":true,"offListPeerReviewed":true},{"id":"genai-creativity-collective-diversity","venue":"Science Advances","inMonitoredSet":false,"determinedTier":null,"recordedTier":"exception","effectiveTier":"exception","kind":"off_list","disclosed":true,"offListPeerReviewed":true},{"id":"theory-of-mind-llms-humans","venue":"Nature Human Behaviour","inMonitoredSet":true,"determinedTier":"A","recordedTier":"S","effectiveTier":"A","kind":"monitored","disclosed":true,"offListPeerReviewed":false},{"id":"algorithmic-responsibility-in-ppc-practice-interpr","venue":"Big Data & Society","inMonitoredSet":true,"determinedTier":"exception","recordedTier":"exception","effectiveTier":"exception","kind":"monitored","disclosed":true,"offListPeerReviewed":false},{"id":"charismatic-machines-on-the-epistemic-power-of-gen","venue":"New Media & Society","inMonitoredSet":true,"determinedTier":"B","recordedTier":"B","effectiveTier":"B","kind":"monitored","disclosed":true,"offListPeerReviewed":false},{"id":"crafting-computer-vision-through-human-eyes-an-ai","venue":"Big Data & Society","inMonitoredSet":true,"determinedTier":"exception","recordedTier":"exception","effectiveTier":"exception","kind":"monitored","disclosed":true,"offListPeerReviewed":false},{"id":"from-prompt-engineering-to-prompt-design-research","venue":"Big Data & Society","inMonitoredSet":true,"determinedTier":"exception","recordedTier":"exception","effectiveTier":"exception","kind":"monitored","disclosed":true,"offListPeerReviewed":false},{"id":"resilience-and-disempowerment-in-algorithmic-syste","venue":"New Media & Society","inMonitoredSet":true,"determinedTier":"B","recordedTier":"B","effectiveTier":"B","kind":"monitored","disclosed":true,"offListPeerReviewed":false},{"id":"working-the-algorithm-contextual-skills-of-on-dema","venue":"Big Data & Society","inMonitoredSet":true,"determinedTier":"exception","recordedTier":"exception","effectiveTier":"exception","kind":"monitored","disclosed":true,"offListPeerReviewed":false},{"id":"backfiring-ai-ai-deployment-in-workplace","venue":"Management Science","inMonitoredSet":true,"determinedTier":"A","recordedTier":"A","effectiveTier":"A","kind":"monitored","disclosed":true,"offListPeerReviewed":false},{"id":"how-costs-influence-preferences-for-control-in-gen","venue":"Information Systems Research","inMonitoredSet":true,"determinedTier":"A","recordedTier":"A","effectiveTier":"A","kind":"monitored","disclosed":true,"offListPeerReviewed":false},{"id":"scp-artificial-intelligence-scp-adoption-and-the-d","venue":"Strategic Management Journal","inMonitoredSet":true,"determinedTier":"S","recordedTier":"S","effectiveTier":"S","kind":"monitored","disclosed":true,"offListPeerReviewed":false},{"id":"when-influencers-delegate-replies-how-social-ai-ag","venue":"Information Systems Research","inMonitoredSet":true,"determinedTier":"A","recordedTier":"A","effectiveTier":"A","kind":"monitored","disclosed":true,"offListPeerReviewed":false},{"id":"artificial-collusion-examining-supracompetitive-pr","venue":"Management Science","inMonitoredSet":true,"determinedTier":"A","recordedTier":"S","effectiveTier":"A","kind":"monitored","disclosed":true,"offListPeerReviewed":false},{"id":"brynjolfsson-li-raymond-generative-ai-at-work-qje-2025","venue":"The Quarterly Journal of Economics","inMonitoredSet":true,"determinedTier":"S","recordedTier":"S","effectiveTier":"S","kind":"monitored","disclosed":true,"offListPeerReviewed":false},{"id":"can-chatgpt-kill-user-generated-qa-platforms","venue":"Information Systems Research","inMonitoredSet":true,"determinedTier":"A","recordedTier":"S","effectiveTier":"A","kind":"monitored","disclosed":true,"offListPeerReviewed":false},{"id":"farach-scaffolding-human-ai-collaboration","venue":"arXiv (working paper)","inMonitoredSet":false,"determinedTier":null,"recordedTier":"exception","effectiveTier":"exception","kind":"off_list","disclosed":true,"offListPeerReviewed":false},{"id":"generative-ai-propaganda-and-digital-authoritarian","venue":"Big Data & Society","inMonitoredSet":true,"determinedTier":"exception","recordedTier":"A","effectiveTier":"exception","kind":"monitored","disclosed":true,"offListPeerReviewed":false},{"id":"made-with-ai-consumer-engagement-with-social-media","venue":"Journal of Consumer Research","inMonitoredSet":true,"determinedTier":"S","recordedTier":"S","effectiveTier":"S","kind":"monitored","disclosed":true,"offListPeerReviewed":false},{"id":"peng-copilot-developer-productivity","venue":"arXiv (working paper)","inMonitoredSet":false,"determinedTier":null,"recordedTier":"exception","effectiveTier":"exception","kind":"off_list","disclosed":true,"offListPeerReviewed":false},{"id":"refusal-as-silence-gendered-disparities-in-vision","venue":"New Media & Society","inMonitoredSet":true,"determinedTier":"B","recordedTier":"A","effectiveTier":"B","kind":"monitored","disclosed":true,"offListPeerReviewed":false},{"id":"the-politics-of-artificial-intelligence-alignment","venue":"New Media & Society","inMonitoredSet":true,"determinedTier":"B","recordedTier":"A","effectiveTier":"B","kind":"monitored","disclosed":true,"offListPeerReviewed":false},{"id":"unraveling-generative-ai-from-a-human-intelligence","venue":"Information Systems Research","inMonitoredSet":true,"determinedTier":"A","recordedTier":"S","effectiveTier":"A","kind":"monitored","disclosed":true,"offListPeerReviewed":false}]}