Uruguay’s personal-assistance decree provides a conditional, household-income-related subsidy towards 80 monthly hours of help with daily life. Access requires the programme’s severe-dependency assessment, living at home and citizenship or residence conditions; admission is phased by age and budget. The user or representatives or agents may contract. Users can request suspension and complain; assistants can end the relationship and complain. These rules do not establish actual recipient control. Programme guidance lists ages 0–29 and over 80, and a cooperative option; the age 80 boundary needs confirmation. This is not a general AI ban, universal available assistance or an individual eligibility assessment.
A funded human option can still leave people with little say, few providers or unsuitable schedules. A family member may value relief that the recipient experiences as lost control. Protecting workers can conflict with an immediate request to change assistants; unrestricted employer power can expose assistants to insecurity or abuse. Neither a staffing label nor collective ownership settles these conflicts.
Compare a funded human option with capable AI, assistive devices, accessible environments, other providers and combinations the person can actually use. Technology may increase privacy or reduce unwanted dependence on another person. Compare safety, usability, control, cost and the ability to change course; do not make human contact compulsory or treat a cheaper tool as an adequate replacement without testing the person’s wanted outcome.
Brazil’s Civil Code Article 1.783-A, inserted in 2015, describes a person with a disability choosing at least two suitable, trusted people with existing ties to provide information for civil decisions. The person requests the arrangement. Its terms set limits, commitments and duration, respecting their will, rights and interests. The judge hears participants personally, with multidisciplinary assistance and public-prosecutor input. Decisions within agreed limits affect third parties; contract counterparties may request countersignatures. Transaction disputes with a supporter involving risk or significant harm go to the judge. Upheld misconduct complaints lead to removal; replacement requires hearing the person and must be in their interest. The person may request termination at any time; supporters need judicial consideration to leave. This inspected text does not establish funded or available support, an AI ban, effectiveness or current individual applicability.
The UN disability-rights committee’s General Comment No. 1, paragraph 29, calls for support based on the person’s will and preferences, affordable access and a right to refuse, change or end support. Use that standard to question gatekeeping, delay and supporter dominance; this is not a finding that the Brazilian mechanism complies with or violates the Convention.
Compare informal voluntary support, a recognised chosen-support arrangement and an independent human advice service. Test where AI assistance expands a person’s choices and where it weakens accountability or control.
Follow the links to the passages listed below. Sources can change. The date we checked a source does not confirm every later change or whether the rule applies to you.