Uruguay’s personal-assistance decree provides a conditional, household-income-related subsidy towards 80 monthly hours of help with daily life. Access requires the programme’s severe-dependency assessment, living at home and citizenship or residence conditions; admission is phased by age and budget. The user or representatives or agents may contract. Users can request suspension and complain; assistants can end the relationship and complain. These rules do not establish actual recipient control. Programme guidance lists ages 0–29 and over 80, and a cooperative option; the age 80 boundary needs confirmation. This is not a general AI ban, universal available assistance or an individual eligibility assessment.
Chile’s Law 21.805 gives unpaid carers priority access to support intended to gradually reduce their caring burden and hours. Carers and recipients can participate in decisions about support they receive or provide. The law links this participation to informed consent and people’s abilities, including children’s and adolescents’ growing ability to decide for themselves.
The law took effect on 16 February 2026. Implementation is gradual. Access depends on programme requirements. The state must offer adequate, necessary and sufficient support, subject to its budget and financial capacity. These provisions set no wage or fixed respite hours. No AI ban is inferred.
A July 2026 government guide describes related home support for moderate or severe dependency. Household registration, local availability and assessment matter; places are limited. This is programme design, not evidence that someone obtained help or time back.
These studies concern different people, places and periods. They do not compare the effects of the selected arrangements, establish current availability or evaluate AI.
This comparison includes no implementation study of Chile’s selected provisions.
An early cooperative pilot
Who was studied
CIEDUR, a Uruguayan research centre, conducted a mixed-method study during August 2023–November 2024. It covered three initial pilot cooperatives in Tacuarembó and Salto. Telephone surveys reached 59 of 62 assistants and 46 of 90 people identified as care contacts for programme users, alongside interviews and workshops.
Reported findings
Respondents described positive working and service experiences; leave cover and cooperative management still presented difficulties.
Limits
Care contacts are not necessarily the people receiving assistance. Responses were incomplete, especially among contacts; possible nonresponse differences remain. This is not a national random sample or causal estimate of autonomy, unpaid work or policy effects.
Human Rights Watch’s 2024 report draws on August 2023 research in Montevideo and Salto: 60 interviewees, including 30 disabled people. Connections used activists, specialists and referrals; many interviewees were outside the programme.
Reported findings
Interviewees described barriers to suitable assistance and independent living; the report also questions recipient influence over support.
Limits
Referral-based qualitative accounts are not prevalence estimates, a matched comparison with the pilot or a current 2026 service census.
A funded human option can still leave people with little say, few providers or unsuitable schedules. A family member may value relief that the recipient experiences as lost control. Protecting workers can conflict with an immediate request to change assistants; unrestricted employer power can expose assistants to insecurity or abuse. Neither a staffing label nor collective ownership settles these conflicts.
Compare a funded human option with capable AI, assistive devices, accessible environments, other providers and combinations the person can actually use. Technology may increase privacy or reduce unwanted dependence on another person. Compare safety, usability, control, cost and the ability to change course; do not make human contact compulsory or treat a cheaper tool as an adequate replacement without testing the person’s wanted outcome.
Can unpaid carers get time back?
Priority on paper may leave people competing for scarce support. Replacing family care with a service may also disrupt a relationship or disregard the recipient’s wishes. More care hours, fewer care hours and a formal priority are each inadequate measures of a good outcome by themselves.
Compare support intended to reduce unpaid care with protected leave to provide or arrange care, and funded personal assistance chosen around the recipient’s needs. A combination may be useful, but costs, access and preferences must be tested rather than assumed.
Change comparison (2 profiles)
Sources and versions checked
Follow the links to the passages listed below. Sources can change. The date we checked a source does not confirm every later change or whether the rule applies to you.