Human by choiceA Policy Window advocacy programme
Policy Window · All HBC reading · Neutral Wiki
Human by choice — a Policy Window advocacy programme · Published 14 November 2026

Human involvement · A discussion aid

What does the promise protect?

Use one proposed AI change to ask who decides, who benefits and what must actually be provided.

Work through this record on your own or in a discussion. Completing it does not establish agreement, representation, legal rights or a decision to proceed.

Notes remain in this open page only. Nothing is sent or saved automatically. Download your notes before closing; a printed copy can also support a discussion. Avoid entering confidential personal information.

Which promises need examining?

Choose any that matter. They can pull in different directions; there is no combined protection score.

The proposed change

Name the workflow, service, task or arrangement. Describe what would change, for whom and where. Do not start by assuming it saves time or is harmful.

1. What should be protected?

Name the contribution, value or benefit. Explain why it matters, including if AI becomes more capable.

2. Who can secure it?

Name the person or institution, actual power, decision stage, duty bearer and route to challenge a failure.

3. Who benefits, who pays and who is outside?

Include workers, service users, entrants, contractors, unpaid carers and people waiting for access where relevant. Identify money, human time and enforcement capacity.

4. What could change the choice?

State the strongest objection and a credible alternative, including keeping the present arrangement or using helpful AI assistance. Say what evidence would change your view.

Evidence and unknowns

Separate observed evidence, source descriptions, forecasts and assumptions. For a rule, record jurisdiction, exact provision, edition and what still needs checking.

Disagreement and next step

Record competing views without inventing agreement. Name the next question, how it could be answered, and who would need authority to act. Leave responsibility unassigned if it has not been accepted.

Printable record (PDF)Read the argument and examples