?asOf= parameter to see the current catalog state.The recurring exclusion of military, intelligence, and national-security AI uses from civilian AI-governance instruments. EU AIA Art. 2(3) explicit exclusion; US EO 14110 §11 + NSM-10 separate track; CoE AI Convention Art. 3 carve-out; UK White Paper sectoral-regulator-only scope; India DPDPA state-security exemptions. China's approach is notable for treating state security as the central concern, not a carveout.
Neutral reference · topicScopeSourcesRecorded catalog review:
Definition & scope
The table covers 45 selected documents. The catalogue records 21 as not addressing this topic; 12 have no classification recorded. These are different states. Neither establishes an absence of law across a jurisdiction.
Coverage across jurisdictions
Historical primacy & cross-jurisdiction tension
First addressed by DFARS Subpart 252.204 (Safeguarding Covered Defense Information and Cyber Incident Reporting) on (governs). This is the earliest matching document in the selected catalogue, not a finding about the first law worldwide or the influence of this document on others.
- Forum-shoppingEU AI Act↔Executive Order 14179 — Removing Barriers to American Leadership in AI
- Forum-shoppingExecutive Order 14110 on Safe, Secure, Trustworthy AI↔Interim Measures for Generative AI Service Management
- Forum-shoppingCouncil of Europe Framework Convention on AI↔G7 Hiroshima AI Process Code of Conduct
Compare jurisdictions: EU vs US · EU vs UK · EU vs CN
Enforcement & impact
Documents recorded as not addressing this topic
These selected documents have an explicit “silent” classification. This does not establish a jurisdiction-wide legal gap. Documents without a classification are identified separately in the table.
- Executive Order 14179 — Removing Barriers to American Leadership in AIUS
- Interim Measures for Generative AI Service ManagementCN
- G7 Hiroshima AI Process Code of ConductG7
- OECD AI Principles (Recommendation)OECD
- UN GA Resolution on Safe, Secure, Trustworthy AIUN
- NIST AI Risk Management FrameworkUS
- Bletchley Declaration on AI Safetyglobal
- Seoul Declaration on Safe, Innovative and Inclusive AIglobal
- NIST AI RMF Generative AI ProfileUS
- California SB-1047: Safe and Secure Innovation for Frontier AI Models ActUS
- Brazil AI Bill (PL 2338/2023)BR
- ASEAN Guide on AI Governance and EthicsASEAN
- African Union Continental AI StrategyAfrican_Union
- Anthropic Responsible Scaling Policy (RSP) v2US
- OpenAI Preparedness FrameworkUS
- Google DeepMind Frontier Safety FrameworkUS
- Meta Frontier AI FrameworkUS
- UK-US AI Safety Institute Memorandum of Understandingglobal
- White House Voluntary AI CommitmentsUS
- Singapore Model AI Governance Framework for Generative AISG
- Japan METI AI Guidelines for BusinessJP
See also
Further reading
14 academic & grey-literature sources bearing on this topic — catalogued metadata with a primary link; one-line findings are ✦ AI-generated summaries, labeled as such (charter §7.9). Browse the full literature index.
- Predictive policing and predictive justice: Ethics, data protection, and the AI act Peer-reviewed✦ AIExamines how predictive-policing and predictive-justice systems interact with data-protection law and the AI Act's law-enforcement provisions, exposing accountability and oversight shortfalls.
- National Security and New Forms of Surveillance: From the Data Retention Saga to a Data Subject Centred Approach Peer-reviewed✦ AIArgues the CJEU's controller-based route for applying EU law to national-security surveillance 'creates significant legal uncertainties,' proposing a data-subject-focused scope instead.
- Cop out: security exemptions in the Artificial Intelligence Act (in: Automating Authority — AI in European police and border regimes) Civil society✦ AIDocuments how AI Act security exemptions plus police powers to restrict supervisory information-sharing will make meaningful supervision of policing and migration AI 'extremely difficult.'
- The AI Act Roller Coaster: The Evolution of Fundamental Rights Protection in the Legislative Process and the Future of the Regulation Peer-reviewed✦ AITraces how the AI Act's law-enforcement and national-security exceptions widened during negotiations, producing 'double standards for fundamental rights protection' and gaps in the regulatory framework.
- Toward a global standard for ethical AI regulation: addressing gaps in AI-driven biometric and high-resolution satellite imaging in the EU AI Act Peer-reviewed✦ AIIdentifies how the AI Act's military, defence and national-security exclusions leave biometric and satellite-imaging surveillance under-regulated, arguing for a global standard to close these gaps.
- Prohibited AI surveillance practices in the Artificial Intelligence Act: promises and pitfalls in protecting fundamental rights Peer-reviewed✦ AIArgues the AI Act's Article 5 surveillance prohibitions are undercut by broad law-enforcement and security exceptions, so 'enforcement of fundamental rights and data protection law' must do the heavy lifting against mass survei…
- The EU AI Act: National Security Implications (CETaS Explainer) Research institute✦ AIExplains the AI Act's national-security exclusion 'does not apply to any dual-use technologies that are also used outside of the national security context,' and that rights groups dispute it.
- Facial Recognition Technology in Policing and Security—Case Studies in Regulation Peer-reviewed✦ AIThrough regulatory case studies, argues facial recognition in policing requires a tailored governance framework grounded in necessity and proportionality rather than ad hoc deployment.
- The AI Act National Security Exception: room for manoeuvres? Think tank✦ AIArgues the AI Act's exclusion of systems used 'exclusively for military, defence or national security purposes' will be destabilised by the unresolved CJEU/member-state contest over what national security means.
- A Struggle for Competence: National Security, Surveillance and the Scope of EU Law at the Court of Justice of European Union Peer-reviewed✦ AIAnalyses how the CJEU in Privacy International and La Quadrature du Net subjected member-state national-security surveillance to EU law, turning the national-security boundary into a contested struggle over competence.
- Big Brother Watch and Others v. the United Kingdom Peer-reviewed✦ AICase note on the ECtHR Grand Chamber's first post-Snowden bulk-interception ruling, holding bulk surveillance not per se disproportionate but requiring end-to-end independent oversight safeguards.
- Bulk Surveillance in the Digital Age: Rethinking the Human Rights Law Approach to Bulk Monitoring of Communications Data Peer-reviewed✦ AIContends 'utility and harm calculations can conceal the complex nature of contemporary digital surveillance practices,' rethinking human-rights-law tests for bulk communications surveillance.
- Data retention as mass surveillance: the need for an evaluative framework Peer-reviewed✦ AIArgues data-retention mandates justified by national security amount to mass surveillance and proposes an evaluative framework because such 'highly intrusive proposals' lack an agreed basis for assessment.
- The Executive Order on Removing Barriers to American Leadership in Artificial Intelligence (implementation tracker) Research institute✦ AIProvision-by-provision tracker of EO 14179 implementation and its America's AI Action Plan follow-on (Jul 2025).
References
The primary instrument sources behind the article's classifications.
- EU-AIA-2024: Art. 2(3) explicitly excludes AI systems used exclusively for military, defence, or national-security purposes
- US-EO-14110: §11 national-security exemption; NSM-10 parallel-track governance for national-security AI
- US-EO-14179: Deregulatory; does not modify national-security carveouts
- UK-WHITEPAPER-2023: Defence + intelligence excluded via sectoral-regulator scope; carveout via omission rather than explicit clause
- CN-GENAI-2023: Distinct framing — state security IS the central concern in China's AI regulation, not a carveout
- G7-HIROSHIMA: Voluntary code does not address national-security carveouts
- OECD-AI-PRIN: Principles do not address carveouts
- COE-AI-CONV: Art. 3 — does not apply to AI used for national security / defence
- UN-RES-2024: High-level resolution; carveouts not addressed
- NIST-AI-RMF: Voluntary framework; carveouts not addressed
- BLETCHLEY-2023: Declaration does not address national-security carveouts
- SEOUL-2024: Frontier AI Safety Commitments do not address carveouts
- NIST-AI-RMF-GENAI: Profile does not address carveouts
- CA-SB-1047: Vetoed; would have applied to covered models including military uses
- IN-DPDP-2023: DPDPA exemptions for state-security functions (Art. 17); not specifically AI but applies
- BR-AIBILL-2024: PL 2338 does not specifically carve out national-security AI
- ASEAN-AI-GUIDE-2024: Non-binding guide; carveouts not addressed
- AU-AI-STRATEGY-2024: Continental strategy; carveouts not addressed
- ANTHROPIC-RSP-2024: RSP applies to all Anthropic models; no national-security carveout in the framework
- OPENAI-PREPAREDNESS-2023: Framework applies across deployments; no national-security carveout specified
- DEEPMIND-FSF-2024: FSF applies across deployments; no carveout specified
- META-FRONTIER-2024: Framework does not address national-security carveouts
- UK-US-AISI-MOU-2024: MoU on joint capability evaluations; defense evaluations exist in parallel under different agreements
- WH-VOLUNTARY-2023: Voluntary commitments do not address carveouts
- SG-MODEL-AI-2024: Framework does not address carveouts
- JP-METI-AI-2024: Guidelines do not address carveouts
- GSA-AI-GUIDE-2024: Guide references existing federal supply-chain risk-management framework (FAR Part 4 Subpart 4.21) which carries national-security overlays
- DOD-RAI-2022: The S&IP IS the DoD-specific RAI framework; tenets + ethical principles operationalise the national-security AI use case rather than carving out from a civilian framework
- FEDRAMP-AI-2024: FedRAMP High baseline + JAB authorisation route exists for higher-sensitivity use cases; classified systems are outside FedRAMP scope and governed by separate ICD-503 / NIST SP 800-53 IC overlay frameworks
- DFARS-252-204: 252.204-7012 + CMMC clauses (-7019/-7020/-7021) are the operative national-security-overlay framework for defence-acquisition information security; the subpart IS the carveout regime
- CN-DEEPSYN-2022: Art. 6, Art. 19 & Art. 20
- IT-AILAW-2025: Art. 6 — activities for national-security purposes by the intelligence services, ACN cybersecurity/resilience, national-defence by the Armed Forces, and certain national-security policing are excluded from the law's scope (subject to fundamental-rights respect; further rules by regulation under l. 124/2007 art. 43).
- JP-AIPROMO-2025: Act No. 53 of 2025, Art. 3(2)
Cite this article 8 formats · BibTeX, RIS, APA, Chicago, … · 1-click copy
Persistent identifier: https://policywindow.org/wiki/national-security-carveouts — committed-stable URL with content-versioning via ?asOf= (rollout pending per methodology §7). DOIs via Zenodo are on the roadmap.
Article tools — track changes, suggest an edit
View history — every captured revision of this article · What links here
12 instruments tracked.