Policy Window

Human by choice · Evidence in practice

Linked to HBC-M008

What each result can establish

Seven evidence records support different questions about one human-care arrangement. They do not add up to an effectiveness score. Formal legal status remains a separate, dated question.

RN means registered nurse; EN means enrolled nurse. QFR means providers’ Quarterly Financial Reports.

reported-delivery

Does reported sector care time exceed the aggregate target?

Whose evidence?
Residential homes in QFS analysis; total denominator count not supplied on cited care-minute page
Unit
care-minute ratio
Calculation/base
total care minutes divided by occupied bed days; not an unweighted mean home or individual allocation
Assurance
Unaudited provider QFR returns with required provider authorisation; department applies validation processes and may request resubmission; exclusions/revisions possible
Limit
No individual time entitlement, distribution, quality or causal effect established
Values, time and source

Period: 2026-04-01 to 2026-06-30

Unit: minutes per occupied bed day

Reported total care time (minutes)
221.22
Sector average target (minutes)
216.86

p13 table 2/notes; p29 methods

Quarterly Financial Snapshot, Q4 2025–26

reported-target-attainment

How many homes are reported as meeting both requirements?

Whose evidence?
Homes in published QFS care-minute analysis; exact N not extracted from this page
Unit
home
Calculation/base
published home attainment percentage, not resident share or volume-weighted minutes
Assurance
Same QFR pipeline as E001, not independent replication
Limit
Complement is not share of residents receiving inadequate care or a home-by-home enforcement finding
Values, time and source

Period: 2026-04-01 to 2026-06-30

Unit: percent of homes in source analysis

Homes meeting total-care target (%)
71.6
Homes meeting nursing target, with EN contribution (%)
83.8
Homes meeting both targets, with EN contribution (%)
66.3

p13 narrative

Quarterly Financial Snapshot, Q4 2025–26

reported-staff-mix

Does the nursing-target figure mean pure RN time?

Whose evidence?
QFS care-minute analysis
Unit
staff-category minute ratio
Calculation/base
sector ratios; RN-with-EN overlaps RN and EN categories and must not be added as another staff category
Assurance
Same QFR pipeline
Limit
48.28 is not pure RN delivery; no new legal interpretation of allowable EN share supplied
Values, time and source

Period: 2026-04-01 to 2026-06-30

Unit: minutes per occupied bed day

Registered-nurse time alone (minutes)
45.25
Registered-nurse time including counted EN contribution (minutes)
48.28
Nursing component target (minutes)
44.2

p13 table 2

Quarterly Financial Snapshot, Q4 2025–26

reported-experience

What do survey participants report about care and agency?

Whose evidence?
2025 resident/proxy survey participants; voluntary participation after within-home random selection
Unit
response to particular fixed question
Calculation/base
published rounded positive response percentages; item bases differ, not all Australians or all residents
Assurance
Published survey results; proxies and nonresponse/selection affect interpretation
Limit
Different period/population from QFS; cannot infer minutes caused experience, nor access for people outside homes. Reported choice does not establish enforceable authority, usable remedies or worker voice.
Values, time and source

Period: 2025-01-01 to 2025-12-31

Unit: percent positive (always/most of time) for selected items; completed-surveys count is not every item denominator

Whole-round completed surveys (not every item denominator)
44,318
Positive answers on daily choice (%)
93
Positive answers on receiving needed care (%)
94

p6 summary; p19 daily-activity result; p11 participation; p51 definitions; p54 survey period

Residents’ Experience Survey: Understanding residents’ experiences, 2023–2025

coded-experience-topic

How frequent are staffing/training mentions within the negative categorised improvement answers?

Whose evidence?
Sentiment-filtered, categorised negative answers to Q14, not whole survey or all residents
Unit
Q14 negative categorised response (may receive multiple topic labels)
Calculation/base
6,608 mentions / 20,193 negative categorised Q14 responses; excludes other sentiments and uncategorised answers
Assurance
LLM topic/sentiment coding; manual taxonomy refinement and sampled validation. Appendix D inconsistencies retained in methods addendum; no reliance on generic accuracy or combined-response total
Limit
Does not estimate population shortage prevalence, strength of preference, or an individual staffing-rule breach
Values, time and source

Period: 2025-01-01 to 2025-12-31

Unit: percent of negative categorised Q14 answers

Answers mentioning staffing or training
6,608
Negative improvement answers assigned a topic
20,193
All improvement-question answers
22,667
Whole-round completed surveys
44,318
Staffing/training mentions within the negative categorised base (%)
32.7

p36; p71–74 tables26/28; p82–83

Residents’ Experience Survey: Understanding residents’ experiences, 2023–2025

funding-design

What reported mechanism links money to delivery?

Whose evidence?
Guidance-defined eligible non-specialised metropolitan homes
Unit
scheme design account
Calculation/base
No actual payment or causal estimate
Assurance
Official guidance; complete legal funding entitlement and actual disbursement unverified
Limit
Do not label observed funding, adequate funding, fair pay or improved care
Values, time and source

Period: 2026-04-01 to not specified

Unit: not-quantified

Observed quantity
Not quantified in this record; source describes a design or process.

Applies to; How supplement works; Recalculating

Care minutes supplement for residential aged care

reporting-assurance-design

What can check the reported care time?

Whose evidence?
Homes subject to departmental reporting-assurance activities
Unit
assurance process account
Calculation/base
No count of completed checks or misreporting prevalence assessed
Assurance
Department describes document checks and possible reporting corrections
Limit
Process existence does not make every QFR datum independently audited or demonstrate enforcement effectiveness
Values, time and source

Period: not specified to not specified

Unit: not-quantified

Observed quantity
Not quantified in this record; source describes a design or process.

How conduct activities; Resubmission; Outcomes

24/7 RN and Care Minutes Reporting Assurance Activities

What remains unestablished

Worker pay, employment, bargaining power and distribution of AI gains are not assessed by these records. Individual care adequacy, entry access and causal effects also remain unresolved.

Download the seven structured evidence records (JSON)